A comparison of lighting technologies used for perimeter security applications

By Todd Brisebois, Product Manager
January 23, 2018

Last week’s Security Digest explored the top four lighting factors – Color Rendering Index (CRI), lumens per Watt (lm/W), color temperature, and lamp life – that can affect the performance and efficiency of perimeter security systems. 

This week, the Security Digest compares four lighting technologies – Low Pressure Sodium (LPS), High Pressure Sodium (HPS), Metal Halide (MH) and Light Emitting Diode (LED) – to determine which has the best combination of these factors. Each has its own advantages and disadvantages, but when it comes to perimeter security applications, there is one that shines brighter than the rest! 

The following table compares the technologies against the four top lighting factors (as well as three other factors that contribute to efficiency – full light spectrum, warm up/cool down time and price). Red indicates poor performance, yellow indicates average performance, and green indicates best performance. 

  LPS  HPS  MH  LED 
Color Rendering Index  0 20–60 60–90 70–95
Lumens/Watt  100–190 80–140 65–115 25–150
Color Temperature  1,800 2,100  3,000 – 20,000 Wide Spectrum
Lamp life (hours)  18,000 24,000 20,000 50,000–100,000
Full light spectrum   √√ √√ √√√
Warm up / Cool down (mins)  5–10 / 15 5–15 / 15 5–15 / 15 Instant
Price  $$$ $$ $$

 

As the table shows, LED-based lighting offers the best combination of factors for perimeter security applications. 

To further explore these technologies and their advantages and disadvantages click here. 

Security Digest is dedicated to providing useful information about physical security. Written by Senstar’s industry experts, the posts will cover a range of subjects related to perimeter intrusion detection, video management and analytics, personal duress, and cyber security. Questions and/or comments? Email [email protected].

Posted Under:
Contáctenos hoy mismo para hablar con un representante de Senstar acerca de sus necesidades de seguridad.